This COSHH assessment addresses the significant health risks associated with MIG and TIG welding of mild and stainless steel, specifically focusing on exposure to hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) and nickel oxide fume. Stainless steel welding generates carcinogenic Cr(VI) at concentrations that routinely exceed the Workplace Exposure Limit (WEL) of 0.025 mg/m³ (8-hour TWA) and 0.05 mg/m³ (15-minute STEL) as specified in EH40/2005. Following HSE Safety Alert STSU1-2019, this assessment mandates on-torch Local Exhaust Ventilation (LEV) as the primary engineering control, supplemented by air-fed Respiratory Protective Equipment (RPE) for operations where LEV alone cannot achieve adequate control. The assessment incorporates a hierarchy of controls including elimination/substitution (where practicable), engineering controls (mandatory on-torch extraction with minimum capture velocity of 1 m/s at 150mm from source), administrative controls (permit-to-work, competency verification, health surveillance under COSHH Regulation 11), and appropriate PPE. All welding operatives must hold valid welding certification, complete COSHH awareness training, and undergo baseline and periodic medical surveillance including respiratory function testing. LEV systems require thorough examination and testing at 14-month intervals per COSHH Regulation 9. This assessment is valid for 12 months or upon significant process change, whichever occurs first.
| Identified Hazard & Harm | Initial Risk (L×S) | Mandatory Engineering, Isolation & Procedural Controls | Residual Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Inhalation of hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) fume from stainless steel welding Harm: Lung cancer, nasal septum perforation, occupational asthma, chrome ulceration of skin. Latency period 10-30 years for malignancy. IARC Group 1 carcinogen. | 5 × 5 = 25 | Mandatory on-torch LEV with minimum 1 m/s capture velocity at 150mm (BS EN ISO 15012-1). Air-fed RPE (APF 40, BS EN 14594) when LEV inadequate. LEV thorough examination every 14 months (COSHH Reg 9). Personal air monitoring (MDHS 52/4) quarterly. Health surveillance (COSHH Reg 11 Schedule 6) including respiratory function tests and biological monitoring (urinary chromium <10 μmol/mol creatinine). Permit-to-work for confined space welding. Substitute austenitic stainless with lower-chromium grades where specification permits. | 3 × 4 = 12 |
| 2. Inhalation of nickel oxide fume and respirable welding particulate Harm: Respiratory sensitisation, occupational asthma, nasal/lung cancer (IARC Group 1), metal fume fever, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). | 5 × 4 = 20 | On-torch LEV with HEPA H13 filtration (BS EN 1822-1) capturing 99.95% of 0.3μm particles. Air-fed RPE for operations exceeding 0.1 mg/m³ nickel WEL. Segregate stainless welding to designated, mechanically ventilated area (minimum 10 air changes/hour). Personal air sampling (IOM sampler, MDHS 14/4) at start of contract and quarterly. Pre-employment and annual respiratory health surveillance including spirometry (FEV1, FVC). Biological monitoring for nickel in urine (end of shift). Prohibit eating/drinking/smoking in welding areas to prevent ingestion. | 3 × 3 = 9 |
| 3. Acute exposure to welding fume in confined spaces or inadequately ventilated areas Harm: Acute respiratory distress, metal fume fever (flu-like symptoms within 4-12 hours), asphyxiation from displacement of oxygen by shielding gas (argon/CO₂), loss of consciousness. | 4 × 5 = 20 | Confined Space Entry Permit mandatory (Confined Spaces Regulations 1997). Pre-entry atmospheric testing (O₂ >19.5%, <23.5%; LEL <10%; toxic gas | 2 × 4 = 8 | |
| 4. Skin contact with hexavalent chromium compounds and nickel sensitisation Harm: Allergic contact dermatitis, chrome ulcers ('chrome holes'), skin sensitisation (Type IV hypersensitivity), potential systemic absorption through damaged skin. | 4 × 3 = 12 | Impervious chrome leather welding gauntlets (BS EN 12477, minimum 400mm length). Flame-retardant coveralls with mandarin collar (BS EN ISO 11611 Class 2) laundered weekly by approved contractor to prevent take-home contamination. Barrier skin creams (pre-work) and emollient creams (post-work) applied to exposed skin. Dedicated washing facilities with warm water, mild soap, and nail brushes provided at exit from welding area. Prohibit dry sweeping; use HEPA-filtered vacuum or wet methods for fume residue removal. Skin surveillance (visual inspection) during health surveillance appointments. Immediate removal from exposure if sensitisation occurs. | 2 × 2 = 4 |
| 5. Failure or inadequate performance of LEV system leading to excessive fume exposure Harm: Chronic exposure to carcinogenic fume exceeding WEL, leading to lung cancer, respiratory disease, and regulatory enforcement action (Improvement/Prohibition Notice). | 4 × 4 = 16 | LEV thorough examination and test (TExT) every 14 months by competent person (COSHH Reg 9, HSG258). Daily pre-use checks by operator (visual inspection, airflow indicator, audible alarm test). Quarterly face velocity measurements at capture hood (target ≥1 m/s at 150mm, record on LEV logbook). Automatic interlock preventing welding equipment operation if LEV fails or airflow drops below 80% of design specification. Standby/backup LEV unit for critical operations. HEPA filter replacement per manufacturer schedule or when pressure drop exceeds design limit. Annual competent person review of LEV effectiveness with personal air monitoring validation. Immediate work cessation if LEV failure detected until repair verified. | 2 × 3 = 6 |
Complete Hot Work Permit and COSHH Task-Specific Risk Assessment. Verify LEV system operational: check airflow indicator shows green/normal, listen for abnormal noise, inspect flexible extraction arm for damage/blockage. Record LEV pre-use check in logbook with date, time, and operative signature. Confirm LEV TExT certificate in date (within 14 months). For confined space work, obtain separate Confined Space Entry Permit with atmospheric test results (O₂, LEL, toxic gas) attached. Verify competency: check welder holds valid coded welder approval (BS EN ISO 9606-1 or equivalent) and COSHH awareness training (refreshed annually). Confirm health surveillance up to date (respiratory questionnaire, spirometry within 12 months). Notify adjacent workers and erect welding screens (BS EN ISO 25980) to protect from UV radiation.
Position on-torch fume extraction nozzle/shroud within 150mm of welding arc and at 45-60° angle to workpiece to maximise capture without interfering with shielding gas flow. Switch on LEV system and allow 30 seconds for airflow stabilisation. Using calibrated anemometer or smoke tube, verify capture velocity ≥1.0 m/s at 150mm from arc position. For fixed LEV hoods, ensure workpiece positioned within effective capture zone (typically 1.5 × hood diameter). Confirm HEPA filter pressure drop within normal range (check manometer/digital display). If welding stainless steel or nickel alloys, don air-fed RPE (BS EN 14594 TH3/TM3, APF 40) and perform positive/negative pressure seal check. Ensure RPE air supply hose does not create trip hazard and is protected from hot work damage. Activate welding fume alarm (if fitted) to alert if LEV fails during operation.
Maintain on-torch extraction nozzle within 150mm of arc throughout welding operation; reposition as work progresses. Avoid blocking extraction inlet with torch body, hands, or workpiece. Monitor LEV airflow indicator continuously; if indicator changes to amber/red or audible alarm sounds, cease welding immediately and investigate. For multi-pass welds, allow 30 seconds between passes for fume clearance. Minimise arc-on time; use pulsed welding parameters where specification permits to reduce fume generation. Avoid welding in direct draught from doors/windows which can disrupt LEV capture efficiency. If welding in confined space, ensure forced ventilation operates continuously and standby person maintains visual/communication contact. Rotate welders every 2 hours for high-fume operations to limit individual exposure. Do not eat, drink, smoke, or apply cosmetics during welding or before washing hands and face.
Allow welded components to cool before handling; use heat-resistant gloves (BS EN 407) if handling warm items. Do not use compressed air to blow dust/fume residue from workpieces or clothing (generates respirable aerosol). Use HEPA-filtered vacuum (H13 minimum) or damp cloth to remove fume deposits from work surfaces and equipment. Store welding consumables (wire, electrodes, flux) in sealed containers in dry, ventilated storage to prevent moisture absorption and hydrogen cracking. Dispose of used welding wire offcuts, slag, and spatter in designated metal waste bins (not general waste). Remove heavily contaminated PPE (gauntlets, coveralls) before leaving welding area to prevent spread of Cr(VI) contamination. Do not take contaminated PPE home for laundering; use approved industrial laundry service.
Continue LEV operation for minimum 5 minutes after final arc extinguished to clear residual fume. Vacuum work area, welding bench, and equipment with HEPA-filtered vacuum; pay attention to horizontal surfaces where fume settles. Wipe down on-torch extraction nozzle and flexible arm with damp cloth. Inspect and empty LEV pre-filter (if fitted) when 70% loaded; dispose of filter media as hazardous waste (EWC 15 02 02*). Remove RPE (if worn) after leaving fume-contaminated area; clean face seal area and store in clean, dry cabinet. Remove welding gauntlets and coveralls; inspect for damage (holes, tears, excessive contamination) and replace if compromised. Wash hands, forearms, face, and neck thoroughly with mild soap and warm water; use nail brush to remove fume deposits from under nails. Apply emollient hand cream. Do not eat, drink, or smoke until washing complete. Report any skin irritation, respiratory symptoms, or equipment defects to supervisor immediately.
Record welding activity in COSHH exposure logbook: date, duration, material welded (mild/stainless steel), LEV system used, any LEV failures/defects, and RPE worn. Sign and date Hot Work Permit closure section; confirm fire watch completed (60 minutes post-welding). For personal air monitoring days (quarterly minimum), wear IOM sampler for full shift; record start/end times and activities. Submit sampler to UKAS-accredited laboratory for analysis (MDHS 52/4 for Cr(VI), MDHS 14/4 for inhalable dust/nickel). Review results with occupational health provider; if exposure >50% WEL, investigate controls and increase monitoring frequency. Attend mandatory health surveillance appointments (baseline, 6 months, then annually): respiratory questionnaire, spirometry (FEV1, FVC), skin inspection, and biological monitoring (urinary chromium). Report any respiratory symptoms (cough, wheeze, breathlessness), skin changes (ulcers, rash), or nasal symptoms (bleeding, crusting) immediately. Maintain personal exposure and health surveillance records for 40 years (COSHH Regulation 12).
Competent Person & Operative Declaration: By signing below, the Site Supervisor confirms this assessment has been adapted and verified for actual site conditions, and operatives confirm they have attended the pre-start Toolbox Talk for Mild & Stainless Steel MIG/TIG Welding Fume (Hexavalent Chromium & Nickel Oxide) and will follow the safe system of work.
| Operative / Supervisor Name | Trade / Role & CSCS No. | Signature | Date & Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. (Site Supervisor): | |||
| 2. | |||
| 3. | |||
| 4. | |||
| 5. | |||
| 6. |